{"id":908,"slug":"nalsinggad-hydro-consultant-selection-073-cr-0118","public_iri":"https://jawafdehi.org/case/nalsinggad-hydro-consultant-selection-073-cr-0118","offence_type":"CORRUPTION","case_type":"CORRUPTION","state":"PUBLISHED","title":"४१० मेगावाटको नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना परामर्शदाता छनौट भ्रष्टाचार मुद्दा: कार्यकारी निर्देशक मोतिबहादुर कुँवरसमेतलाई सफाई (073-CR-0118)","short_description":"अख्तियार दुरुपयोग अनुसन्धान आयोगले विशेष अदालतमा दायर गरेको मुद्दा 073-CR-0118, प्रतिवादी: मोतिबहादुर कुँवर समेत ६।","authors":[{"slug":"gaurav-karki","display_name":"Gaurav Karki","name_ne":"गौरव कार्की","photo_url":"https://jawafdehi.org/assets/teammembers/gaurav.webp","title":"Caseworker","has_public_page":true}],"case_publish_date":"2026-09-23","public_edit_history":[],"public_notes":"","thumbnail":null,"banner":null,"thumbnail_image_id":null,"banner_image_id":null,"thumbnail_url":"","banner_url":"","case_start_date":"2017-04-02","case_end_date":"2017-12-05","dates":{"stages":[{"end":"2017-12-05","stage":"initial","start":"2017-04-02","courtcase_iri":"https://jawafdehi.org/courtcase/special/073-cr-0118"},{"end":"2019-05-08","stage":"appeal","start":"2018-04-26","courtcase_iri":"https://jawafdehi.org/courtcase/supreme/074-cr-1293"}]},"status":"concluded","case_track":null,"status_override":null,"proceedings_started_on":"2017-04-02","proceedings_decided_on":"2019-05-08","appeal_verdicts":{"https://jawafdehi.org/courtcase/supreme/074-cr-1293":"AFFIRMED"},"appeal_parties":{"https://jawafdehi.org/courtcase/supreme/074-cr-1293":["https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/anandaprasada-capagai","https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/gokarnaraja-pantha","https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/motibahadura-ku-vara","https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/rajeshakumara-thapa","https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/suryaprasada-rijala","https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/udipalala-shreshtha"]},"entities":[{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/motibahadura-ku-vara","display_name":"मोतिबहादुर कुँवर","entity_type":"Person","type":"accused","outcome":"acquitted","notes":"कार्यकारी निर्देशक, नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना विकास समिति","name":{"en":"मोतिबहादुर कुँवर","ne":null},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/suryaprasada-rijala","display_name":"सुर्यप्रसाद रिजाल","entity_type":"Person","type":"accused","outcome":"acquitted","notes":"सदस्य, प्रस्ताव मूल्याङ्कन समिति, नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना","name":{"en":"सुर्यप्रसाद रिजाल","ne":null},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/gokarnaraja-pantha","display_name":"गोकर्णराज पन्थ","entity_type":"Person","type":"accused","outcome":"acquitted","notes":"सिनियर डिभिजनल इन्जिनियर, उर्जा मन्त्रालय","name":{"en":"गोकर्णराज पन्थ","ne":null},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/rajeshakumara-thapa","display_name":"राजेशकुमार थापा","entity_type":"Person","type":"accused","outcome":"acquitted","notes":"सदस्य, प्रस्ताव मूल्याङ्कन समिति, नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना","name":{"en":"राजेशकुमार थापा","ne":null},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/anandaprasada-capagai","display_name":"आनन्दप्रसाद चापागाई","entity_type":"Person","type":"accused","outcome":"acquitted","notes":"लेखा अधिकृत, नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना विकास समिति","name":{"en":"आनन्दप्रसाद चापागाई","ne":null},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/udipalala-shreshtha","display_name":"उदीपलाल श्रेष्ठ","entity_type":"Person","type":"accused","outcome":"acquitted","notes":"प्रस्तावदाता परामर्शदाता पक्षको वारेस","name":{"en":"उदीपलाल श्रेष्ठ","ne":null},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/location/district/jajarkot-np0660","display_name":"Jajarkot","entity_type":"AdministrativeArea,jawafdehi:District","type":"location","outcome":null,"notes":"नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना (४१० मेगावाट) रहेको जिल्ला","name":{"en":"Jajarkot","ne":"जाजरकोट"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/government/ministry-of-energy","display_name":"Ministry of Energy","entity_type":"GovernmentOrganization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"विशेषज्ञहरूको श्रम स्वीकृतिको कारबाही अगाडि बढाउने निकाय","name":{"en":"Ministry of Energy","ne":"ऊर्जा मन्त्रालय"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/government/department/department-of-electricity-development","display_name":"Department of Electricity Development","entity_type":"GovernmentOrganization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"प्रतिवादी राजेशकुमार थापा कार्यरत सरकारी निकाय","name":{"en":"Department of Electricity Development","ne":"विद्युत विकास विभाग"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/government/body/nalsing-gad-hydropower-project-development-committee","display_name":"Nalsing Gad Hydropower Project Development Committee","entity_type":"GovernmentOrganization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"परामर्शदाता छनौट गर्ने आयोजना; हानी नोक्सानी भएको सरकारी निकाय","name":{"en":"Nalsing Gad Hydropower Project Development Committee","ne":"नलसिङगाड जलविद्युत आयोजना विकास समिति"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/smec-mwh-uday-jv","display_name":"SMEC-MWH-Uday JV","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"बढी रकम कबोल गरी बढी अङ्क पाएको संयुक्त उद्यम","name":{"en":"SMEC-MWH-Uday JV","ne":"SMEC-MWH-Uday JV"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/af-consult-switzerland-ltd-hydro-consult-engineering-ltd-and-nepal","display_name":"AF-Consult Switzerland Ltd., Hydro-Consult Engineering Ltd. and Nepal Environmental and Scientific Services Pvt. Ltd. JV","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"कम रकम कबोल गर्ने तर कम अङ्क दिइएको प्रस्तावक JV","name":{"en":"AF-Consult Switzerland Ltd., Hydro-Consult Engineering Ltd. and Nepal Environmental and Scientific Services Pvt. Ltd. JV","ne":"AFC-HCE-NESS JV"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/smec-international-pty-limited","display_name":"SMEC International Pty Limited","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC-MWH JV को सदस्य; अख्तियारी र MoU को छाप विवादित","name":{"en":"SMEC International Pty Limited","ne":"SMEC International Pty Limited"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/mwh-international-inc","display_name":"MWH International Inc.","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC सँग JV गर्ने कम्पनी; Power of Attorney को वैधता विवादित","name":{"en":"MWH International Inc.","ne":"MWH International Inc."},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/udaya-consultancy-pvt-ltd","display_name":"Udaya Consultancy Pvt. Ltd.","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC-MWH JV का नेपाली सहयोगी कम्पनी","name":{"en":"Udaya Consultancy Pvt. Ltd.","ne":"Udaya Consultancy P. Ltd."},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/beth-knackstedt","display_name":"Beth Knackstedt","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"MWH को तर्फबाट MoU र अख्तियारीनामामा दस्तखत गर्ने","name":{"en":"Beth Knackstedt","ne":"Beth Knackstedt"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/smec-international-pty-ltd","display_name":"SMEC International Pty Ltd","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"ठेक्का पाएको JV को नेतृत्वकर्ता परामर्शदाता कम्पनी, अष्ट्रेलिया","name":{"en":"SMEC International Pty Ltd","ne":"SMEC International Pty Ltd"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/udaya-consultancy-p-ltd","display_name":"Udaya Consultancy (P) Ltd.","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC-MWH JV को सहयोगी नेपाली परामर्शदाता कम्पनी","name":{"en":"Udaya Consultancy (P) Ltd.","ne":"उदय कन्सल्टेन्सी (प्रा.) लि."},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/af-consultant-jv-afc-hce-ness","display_name":"AF Consultant JV (AFC-HCE-NESS)","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"प्रतिस्पर्धी JV, मूल्याङ्कनमा घटी अङ्क पाएको","name":{"en":"AF Consultant JV (AFC-HCE-NESS)","ne":"AF Consultant (AFC-HCE-NESS JV)"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/motibahadur-kunwar","display_name":"Motibahadur Kunwar","entity_type":"Person","type":"alleged","outcome":null,"notes":"कार्यकारी निर्देशक, मूल्याङ्कन समिति अध्यक्ष, प्रतिवेदन स्वीकृत गर्ने","name":{"en":"Motibahadur Kunwar","ne":"मोतिवहादुर कुँवर"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/mohiuddin-mahmud","display_name":"Mohiuddin Mahmud","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC का तर्फबाट वार्ता गर्न ढिलो अख्तियारी पाएका प्रतिनिधि","name":{"en":"Mohiuddin Mahmud","ne":"Mohiuddin Mahmud"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/punya-prasad-oli","display_name":"Punya Prasad Oli","entity_type":"Person","type":"alleged","outcome":null,"notes":"Senior Surveyor प्रस्तावित, परिषद दर्ता नभई झुठ्ठा CV प्रमाणित","name":{"en":"Punya Prasad Oli","ne":"पुण्य प्रसाद ओली"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/philip-wilcox","display_name":"Philip Wilcox","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC का Company Secretary, अख्तियारीनामामा हस्ताक्षरकर्ता","name":{"en":"Philip Wilcox","ne":"Philip Wilcox"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/angus-macpherson","display_name":"Angus Macpherson","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"SMEC का Director, अख्तियारीनामामा हस्ताक्षरकर्ता","name":{"en":"Angus Macpherson","ne":"Angus Macpherson"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/jeff-d-agosta","display_name":"Jeff D'Agosta","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"MWH का Secretary, अख्तियारीनामामा हस्ताक्षरकर्ता","name":{"en":"Jeff D'Agosta","ne":"Jeff D'Agosta"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/daniel-mcconville","display_name":"Daniel McConville","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"MWH का Senior Vice President, अख्तियारीनामामा हस्ताक्षरकर्ता","name":{"en":"Daniel McConville","ne":"Daniel McConville"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/government/department/ministry-of-energy","display_name":"Ministry of Energy","entity_type":"GovernmentOrganization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"प्रतिवादी गोकर्णराज पन्थ कार्यरत सरकारी निकाय","name":{"en":"Ministry of Energy","ne":"उर्जा मन्त्रालय"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/afc-hce-ness-jv","display_name":"AFC-HCE-NESS JV","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"प्रस्ताव पेश गर्ने परामर्शदाता JV, घटी अङ्क पाएको र कम रकम कवोल गरेको","name":{"en":"AFC-HCE-NESS JV","ne":"AFC-HCE-NESS"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/organization/contractor/smec-mwh-udaya-jv","display_name":"SMEC-MWH-Udaya JV","entity_type":"Organization","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"बढी अङ्क पाएको र बढी रकम कवोल गर्ने परामर्शदाता JV","name":{"en":"SMEC-MWH-Udaya JV","ne":"SMEC-MWH-Uday"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/richard-longden","display_name":"Richard Longden","entity_type":"Person","type":"related","outcome":null,"notes":"AFC-HCE-NESS ले प्रस्ताव गरेको Geotechnical Engineer","name":{"en":"Richard Longden","ne":"Richard Longden"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/abi-karmacharya","display_name":"Abi Karmacharya","entity_type":"Person","type":"witness","outcome":null,"notes":"प्रतिवादी उदीपलाल श्रेष्ठको साक्षी, बकपत्र गरेको","name":{"en":"Abi Karmacharya","ne":"अबी कर्माचार्य"},"image":null},{"nes_id":"https://jawafdehi.org/entity/person/ishwor-nepal","display_name":"Ishwor Nepal","entity_type":"Person","type":"witness","outcome":null,"notes":"प्रतिवादी मोतीबहादुर कुँवरको साक्षी, बकपत्र गरेको","name":{"en":"Ishwor Nepal","ne":"ईश्‍वर नेपाल"},"image":null}],"tags":["भ्रष्टाचार","अनियमितता"],"description":"","key_allegations":[],"timeline":[],"ai_generated_sections":[],"evidence":[{"material_iri":"https://jawafdehi.org/material/court_order/special.073-cr-0118","additional_details":"","material":{"display_name":"Special Court verdict: 073-CR-0118 · Irregularity","material_type":"court_order","urls":[{"link":"https://s3.jawafdehi.org/case_uploads/court-orders/special/073-CR-0118.1.doc","role":"RAW"},{"link":"https://s3.jawafdehi.org/case_uploads/64b29bc7087611955c2b87808f95934bf87eef6ef1ce3287449ef5d4f2e65808.md","role":"MARKDOWN"},{"link":"https://s3.jawafdehi.org/case_uploads/5da7d23a5f1c60c504f5e29a6cc4245041fd9d85ab4b3ab5b8e04b67ebbb31c1.md","role":"REDACTED_MARKDOWN"}]}},{"material_iri":"https://jawafdehi.org/material/court_order/supreme.074-cr-1293","additional_details":"","material":{"display_name":"Supreme Court verdict: 074-CR-1293 · Corruption","material_type":"court_order","urls":[{"link":"https://s3.jawafdehi.org/case_uploads/30861bf1b6981a4c9a90a9f4be9ec9824f8157c76e018d8701a1cb95699ac345.doc","role":"RAW"},{"link":"https://s3.jawafdehi.org/case_uploads/360ca305ef623d4a658bb620717c426e669f0eb4efbe7fe171cf8f21fa9b96ba.md","role":"REDACTED_MARKDOWN"}]}}],"notes":"","court_cases":["https://jawafdehi.org/courtcase/special/073-cr-0118","https://jawafdehi.org/courtcase/supreme/074-cr-1293"],"missing_details":"१. यस मुद्दामा अख्तियारले जारी गरेको प्रेश विज्ञप्ती र आरोपपत्र सार्वजनिक भएको छैन भने यसमा उल्लिखित विवरणहरु विशेष अदालतको फैसलामा आधारित छन्।\n२. सर्वोच्च अदालतको फैसलाको पूर्णपाठ ।","bigo":272454351,"weight":0,"versionInfo":{"action":"published","datetime":"2026-09-28T13:28:11.192675+00:00"},"created_at":"2026-06-10T15:21:21.395087+05:45","updated_at":"2026-11-02T17:25:37.540417+05:45"}